Mahi Way finds Mahi Talwar (Pushtiie Shakti) from a family with a father that pampers her, a beautiful sister, and a mother who sidelines her. However, Mahi, irrespective of her weight issues tries to live her life in her own way even though she gets laughed at. This chubby girl is in search of true love as well and has a crush on Ishan Singh Ahluwalia (Siddhant Karnick). While she goes against the narrow standards of beauty set by society, the events of the hilarious series are commenced.